daily californian logo

BERKELEY'S NEWS • MAY 26, 2023

Apply to The Daily Californian!

Law students react to Boalt Hall name change

article image

AMANDA RAMIREZ | STAFF

SUPPORT OUR NONPROFIT NEWSROOM

We're an independent student-run newspaper, and need your support to maintain our coverage.

NOVEMBER 14, 2018

A day after UC Berkeley School of Law Dean Erwin Chemerinsky announced he is recommending to campus administration changing the name of Boalt Hall, campus law students expressed both support and doubt over the efficacy of the decision.

Many students shared the sentiment that the move was a positive change if it induced a more inclusive environment.

“I don’t think a symbol like (Boalt) should represent an institution like Berkeley Law,” said Berkeley School of Law third-year Sadat Tabatabai.

The building’s namesake, John Boalt, is infamous for his anti-Chinese rhetoric and racist remarks against Black people and Native Americans.

The announcement comes after the Committee on the Use of the Boalt Name issued a report in September recommending that such steps be taken and after Chemerinsky reportedly changed his mind “several times.”

Other students doubted the impact of the name change. According to Alejandro Gonzalez, in his home country of Colombia, Boalt is a recognizable brand, and he is unsure how the name change will affect this.

Meanwhile, campus law student Eleazar Saldivia noted discrepancies with the treatment of monuments to figures with histories of owning slaves such as George Washington and Thomas Jefferson.

Chemerinsky addressed some of these arguments in his announcement, contending that some historical figures owned slaves or said racist things but still have “good reasons” to be honored “notwithstanding their racist statements and actions.”

According to Chemerinsky, the official name of the law school has never been “Boalt,” and the Berkeley name was intentionally used because of its international reputation.

Another Berkeley Law student, Pablo Kusulas, said he believes it is more important for the campus community to look to the future.

“A cool thing about Berkeley is that we’re very inclusive and we don’t discriminate over anything, but I think here we’re being oversensitive,” Kusulas said. “I think it’s pointless to change the past. We need to look to the future to avoid this happening again.”

Charles Cannon, a Berkeley Law administrator and chair of the Committee on the Use of the Boalt Name, said the committee met for nine months and had “literally thousands” of conversations as they attempted to sort out any confusion regarding the use of the name.

Cannon said the committee ultimately decided unanimously to recommend changing the name because of John Boalt’s lack of social contribution to “offset” his racist actions.

“A school of this stature shouldn’t bear (Boalt’s) name,” Cannon said.

According to Chemerinsky, the recommendation will be considered by the campus Building Name Review Committee and will then require approval by Chancellor Carol Christ and eventually UC President Janet Napolitano.

“In the end,” Chemerinsky concluded in his announcement, “I am reassured that we are all united in our desire to make this one of the finest law schools in the world.”

Contact Alex Teodorescu at [email protected] and follow him on Twitter at @AlexTeodorescu8.
LAST UPDATED

NOVEMBER 15, 2018


Related Articles

featured article
The commission plans to meet with the presidents and lead advisers of the UC Berkeley Interfraternity Council and Panhellenic Council next week to discuss future action.
The commission plans to meet with the presidents and lead advisers of the UC Berkeley Interfraternity Council and Panhellenic Council next week to discuss future action.
featured article
featured article
UC Berkeley librarians, wearing blue tape on their mouths and shirts that read “librarians will not be silent,” met Friday on the steps of Doe Memorial Library for a protest regarding contract negotiations with the University of California that began April 16.
UC Berkeley librarians, wearing blue tape on their mouths and shirts that read “librarians will not be silent,” met Friday on the steps of Doe Memorial Library for a protest regarding contract negotiations with the University of California that began April 16.
featured article
featured article
About 20 people — ranging from UC Berkeley graduate students to elderly community members — strolled, or wheeled, into Dwinelle Hall on Monday, where they heard Theresia Degener, the only female member and chair of the United Nations, or U.N., Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, speak about her work on the committee.
About 20 people — ranging from UC Berkeley graduate students to elderly community members — strolled, or wheeled, into Dwinelle Hall on Monday, where they heard Theresia Degener, the only female member and chair of the United Nations, or U.N., Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, speak about her work on the committee.
featured article